Indian cricketer Mohammed Shami has recently been at the center of controversy, facing criticism from certain religious clerics for his personal and familial practices. Initially, Shami was targeted for not observing Roza (fasting) during the holy month of Ramadan while participating in the ICC Champions Trophy 2025. Subsequently, his daughter became the subject of criticism for participating in Holi celebrations, a festival traditionally associated with Hinduism.
Criticism Over Not Observing Roza
During the ICC Champions Trophy 2025, Mohammed Shami was seen consuming an energy drink during India’s semi-final match against Australia. This act led Maulana Shahabuddin Razvi Bareilvi, President of the All India Muslim Jamaat, to publicly criticize Shami for not observing Roza during Ramadan. The cleric labeled Shami’s actions as “criminal” from a religious standpoint, stating that fasting during Ramadan is a compulsory duty for healthy individuals. He emphasized that failing to observe Roza is considered a significant violation of Shariat (Islamic law), and individuals neglecting this duty would have to answer to God.
Targeting of Shami’s Daughter for Holi Celebrations
The scrutiny extended to Shami’s family when his daughter was criticized for participating in Holi festivities. Maulana Shahabuddin Razvi expressed disapproval, asserting that Holi is a Hindu festival and that Muslims should avoid such celebrations, labeling participation as a sin. He argued that engaging in festivals of other religions is against Shariat principles and that Muslims should refrain from these practices to maintain religious purity.
Public and Community Reactions
The cleric’s remarks have sparked a broader debate within the community and among the public. Many have come forward to support Shami, emphasizing the importance of personal choice in religious observance and the need to respect individual decisions. Critics of the cleric’s stance argue that such rigid interpretations of religious practices can lead to unnecessary divisions and overlook the pluralistic fabric of society.
Support from Shami’s Coach
In response to the criticisms, Shami’s coach, Mohammed Badruddin, defended the cricketer’s choices. He highlighted the importance of national duty and personal discretion in matters of religious observance. Badruddin emphasized that representing the country on an international platform is a significant responsibility and that personal religious practices should not overshadow professional commitments. He urged critics to prioritize national pride and respect individual choices, stating, “Desh ke aage kuch nahin” (Nothing comes before the nation).
Balancing Professional Commitments and Religious Practices
The situation brings to light the challenges faced by professional athletes in balancing their careers with personal religious practices. Athletes often perform under physically demanding conditions that may not align with certain religious observances, such as fasting. The debate underscores the need for a nuanced understanding of individual circumstances and the importance of personal autonomy in matters of faith.
Conclusion
The criticisms directed at Mohammed Shami and his family highlight the complexities surrounding personal religious practices in a diverse society. While religious leaders may offer interpretations based on doctrinal beliefs, it is essential to respect individual choices and recognize the pluralistic nature of contemporary communities. The support for Shami from various quarters reflects a broader acceptance of personal autonomy and the importance of unity beyond religious differences.
